Edge on Hudson vs Landmark Condo: The Best Tarrytown Real Estate Value in 2025
Considering a property purchase in Tarrytown? Many buyers are weighing the options between the historic Landmark Condominium and the new Edge on Hudson development. We've compiled answers to the most common questions to help you make an informed decision.
What makes Landmark Condo a better value than Edge on Hudson?
The Landmark Condominium offers exceptional value at approximately half the price of comparable Edge on Hudson properties. With significantly lower monthly HOA fees ($481 vs $700+) and annual taxes ($4,381 vs $8,000+), the Landmark Condo provides substantial long-term savings while offering historic charm in a prime, walkable location.
How do the locations compare for commuters and lifestyle?
The Landmark Condo at 18 N Broadway boasts a superior 90/100 walkability score, with Metro-North just a 5-minute walk away for an easy 40-minute commute to NYC. You'll be steps from Tarrytown Music Hall, restaurants, and shops. Edge on Hudson, while offering river views, is more car-dependent for daily errands and entertainment.
What are the architectural differences between the properties?
The Landmark Condominium represents a thoughtfully converted historic schoolhouse designed by Rosaria Piomelli, the first woman to serve as Dean of any architectural school in the USA. This offers unique character, high ceilings, and architectural significance that new construction at Edge on Hudson simply cannot replicate.
Which property offers better appreciation potential?
Historic properties in walkable locations have demonstrated strong value retention, particularly as buyers increasingly prioritize character and convenience. While Edge on Hudson offers newer amenities, the Landmark Condo's combination of historic significance, lower carrying costs, and prime location positions it favorably for long-term appreciation in the Tarrytown market.
Edge on Hudson vs Landmark Condo: The Best Tarrytown Real Estate Value in 2025
Considering a move to beautiful Tarrytown, New York? Many prospective buyers find themselves comparing the historic Landmark Condominium with the newer Edge on Hudson development. We've compiled answers to the most common questions to help you make an informed decision.
How much can I save choosing Landmark Condo over Edge on Hudson?
The savings are substantial. The Landmark Condo at 18 N Broadway #402 is priced at $500,000, while comparable Edge on Hudson properties start at $1,000,000+. Beyond the purchase price, you'll also save significantly on monthly HOA fees ($481 vs $700+) and annual taxes ($4,381 vs $8,000+). For many buyers, this represents hundreds of thousands in upfront savings plus thousands annually in carrying costs.
Which location offers better walkability and convenience?
The Landmark Condominium offers exceptional walkability with a score of 90/100, as it's located steps from the Tarrytown Music Hall, restaurants, shops, and just a 5-minute walk to Metro-North for an easy 40-minute commute to NYC. Edge on Hudson, while featuring waterfront views, is considerably more car-dependent for daily needs and conveniences.
What architectural differences should I consider?
The Landmark Condominium was thoughtfully converted from a historic schoolhouse (built 1897) with conversion designed by Rosaria Piomelli, the first woman to serve as Dean of any architectural school in the USA. It features unique historic character with soaring ceilings and abundant natural light. Edge on Hudson offers modern construction with contemporary finishes but lacks the unique character and history of the Landmark building.
Do I sacrifice modern amenities with a historic building?
Not at all. The Landmark Condo features updated appliances, modern HVAC, in-unit laundry, elevator access, and a reserved parking space. The open floor plan creates a spacious feeling despite the efficient 785 square feet, and includes conveniences like a powder room for guests and a kitchen with stainless steel appliances.
Which property offers better investment potential?
Historic properties in walkable locations have consistently shown strong value retention and appreciation potential. With the Landmark Condo, you're investing in a unique property with irreplaceable historic character at half the price of new construction, in a highly desirable location. The lower carrying costs also mean more of your monthly payment goes toward building equity.
Ready to experience the exceptional value of the Landmark Condominium for yourself? Schedule a viewing today and discover why this historic Tarrytown treasure represents the smartest real estate investment in Westchester County for 2025.
Edge on Hudson vs Landmark Condo: The Best Tarrytown Real Estate Value in 2025
Considering a move to beautiful Tarrytown, NY? Many prospective buyers have questions about the value proposition between historic properties like the Landmark Condominium and new developments like Edge on Hudson. Here are answers to the most common questions we receive:
Which offers better value: Edge on Hudson or Landmark Condominiums?
Dollar for dollar, Landmark Condominiums offer significantly better value in 2025. At approximately $500,000, you can own a charming, historic property in the heart of Tarrytown with half the monthly expenses of comparable Edge on Hudson units which typically start at $1,000,000+. The Landmark Condo at 18 N Broadway features lower HOA fees ($481 vs $700+) and substantially lower annual taxes ($4,381 vs $8,000+), providing both immediate savings and long-term financial benefits.
How does the location compare between Landmark Condo and Edge on Hudson?
The Landmark Condominium offers superior walkability with a remarkable 90/100 walk score. Located steps from the historic Tarrytown Music Hall, Metro-North station, and Main Street's restaurants and shops, you'll enjoy true village living. Edge on Hudson, while offering Hudson River views, is generally considered car-dependent for most daily activities, requiring additional transportation costs and time that Landmark residents don't face.
Do historic buildings like the Landmark Condo have modern amenities?
Absolutely! The Landmark Condominium has been thoughtfully updated to include all modern conveniences while preserving its historic character. You'll enjoy stainless steel appliances, modern HVAC systems, in-unit laundry, elevator access, and even a powder room for guests. Unlike some misconceptions about historic properties, the Landmark offers the perfect balance of 1897 architectural charm with contemporary functionality.
What's the investment potential of Landmark Condo vs Edge on Hudson?
Historic properties in walkable locations have consistently demonstrated strong value retention and appreciation potential. While Edge on Hudson offers new construction appeal, the Landmark Condominium provides unique historic character that cannot be replicated, creating inherent scarcity value. With half the purchase price and monthly expenses of Edge on Hudson, Landmark owners start with substantially better cash flow and more financial flexibility.
How does the Landmark Condominium accommodate modern lifestyles?
The Landmark Condo has been thoughtfully designed to support contemporary living. The pet-friendly building includes a reserved parking space, elevator access, and an efficient 785 square foot floor plan that maximizes living space. The central Tarrytown location means you're just steps from dining, entertainment, shopping, and transportation, offering the walkable lifestyle increasingly sought by today's homebuyers.
Inside Your Landmark Condominium
Experience elegant living in this unique Landmark Condo in Tarrytown, New York. Just steps from the historic Tarrytown Music Hall, Metro-North, and vibrant Main Street. Enjoy all the charm of a historic building while paying half the price of Edge on Hudson properties!
Step into your Landmark Condominium through a welcoming entryway that beautifully blends historic Tarrytown character with modern updates. The elevator opens directly to your floor, providing convenience that rivals even the new Edge on Hudson developments.
The updated kitchen in your Landmark Condo features stainless steel appliances, generous cabinet space, and a layout perfect for preparing meals before heading out to enjoy Tarrytown Music Hall performances. Recent upgrades ensure modern functionality within historic surroundings.
The bright bedroom in this Tarrytown, New York residence offers a peaceful retreat with space for a king-sized bed. Unlike many units at Edge on Hudson, this Landmark Condominium includes the luxury of 1.5 bathrooms—a full bath with quality fixtures and a convenient powder room for guests.
Edge on Hudson vs Landmark Condo: The Best Tarrytown Real Estate Value in 2025
Considering real estate in Tarrytown? Here are answers to the most common questions buyers are asking about these two popular options.
Is Edge on Hudson worth the premium price compared to Landmark Condominiums?
While Edge on Hudson offers new construction with modern amenities, Landmark Condominiums provide comparable features at approximately half the price. For $500,000, you get historic character, modern updates, and the same walkable access to Tarrytown's amenities that Edge on Hudson residents enjoy at twice the cost. The value proposition of Landmark Condos is particularly compelling when considering price per square foot in Tarrytown's real estate market.
How do the locations compare between Landmark Condo and Edge on Hudson?
Both offer excellent Tarrytown locations, but with different advantages. Edge on Hudson provides Hudson River views and waterfront access. Landmark Condominiums offer superior walkability to Tarrytown's cultural center, with the historic Tarrytown Music Hall, Metro-North station, and Main Street shops and restaurants literally steps from your door. Many residents find the central village location more practical for daily living.
What about maintenance costs and taxes?
Landmark Condominiums typically have lower carrying costs. With HOA fees of $481/month and taxes around $4,381/year, the ongoing expenses are significantly lower than comparable Edge on Hudson properties. New construction often comes with higher property tax assessments and HOA fees, making the Landmark Condo's total monthly payment much more affordable over time.
Are there differences in construction quality?
Edge on Hudson features modern construction techniques, while Landmark Condominiums showcase the craftsmanship of 1897 with thoughtful modern updates. The historic building's solid construction has stood the test of time for over 125 years. Recent renovations ensure all systems meet modern standards while preserving architectural details that simply cannot be replicated in new construction.
Which property type has better appreciation potential?
Historic properties in established neighborhoods like the Landmark Condominium often maintain steady appreciation due to their unique character and limited supply. While Edge on Hudson may see initial appreciation as the development completes, historic properties in prime walkable locations have consistently demonstrated strong value retention in Westchester County over decades.
Edge on Hudson vs Landmark Condo: The Best Tarrytown Real Estate Value in 2025
Considering a move to Tarrytown, New York? As local real estate experts, we're answering the most common questions buyers are asking about Landmark Condominiums compared to Edge on Hudson properties.
How much can I save by choosing a Landmark Condo over Edge on Hudson?
The savings are substantial. Landmark Condominiums are priced around $500,000—approximately half the cost of comparable units at Edge on Hudson. Additionally, you'll benefit from lower HOA fees ($481/month) and significantly reduced property taxes (approximately $4,381/year) compared to the newer development. Over a 10-year period, this could translate to hundreds of thousands in savings while still enjoying Tarrytown's premier location.
What amenities do I get with a Landmark Condo in Tarrytown?
Landmark Condos offer 785 square feet of efficiently designed space in a historic building (built 1897) that has been thoughtfully converted and regularly updated. The HOA fee ($481/month) covers common area maintenance, exterior upkeep, snow removal, and trash service. Beyond the building itself, you're steps away from Tarrytown Music Hall, Metro-North station, and the charming Main Street—amenities that are part of the authentic Tarrytown experience and within the highly-rated Union Free School District of the Tarrytowns.
How does the Landmark Condo compare to other Tarrytown properties?
Recent comparable sales in Tarrytown confirm the Landmark Condo's exceptional value:
  • 19 Windle Park Unit B (1BR, 867 sq ft): $515,000 (May 2025)
  • 9 Windle Park Unit B (1BR, 864 sq ft): $475,555 (Mar 2025)
  • 66 Riverview Ave (2BR, 1,040 sq ft): $735,000 (Mar 2025)
The Landmark Condo offers historic character and prime location at a price point that remains competitive in Tarrytown's desirable market.
Is a historic Landmark Condo as convenient as a new Edge on Hudson property?
Absolutely! With a 90/100 walkability score, the Landmark Condo actually offers superior convenience for many buyers. You're just 5 minutes from Metro-North (40-minute ride to Grand Central), and within walking distance to all of Tarrytown's shops, restaurants, and cultural attractions. While Edge on Hudson offers new construction, the Landmark Condo provides authentic character with modern updates in a more established, walkable location—without requiring a car for daily errands.
Is the Landmark Condo a good investment compared to Edge on Hudson?
The Landmark Condo represents an exceptional investment opportunity. With lower entry costs, reduced carrying costs (taxes and HOA), and location in Tarrytown's established historic district, these properties have demonstrated consistent value appreciation. While Edge on Hudson offers the premium of new construction, the Landmark Condo provides immediate savings and the unique character that continues to attract buyers to Tarrytown's historic properties.
Edge on Hudson vs Landmark Condo: The Best Tarrytown Real Estate Value in 2025
Considering a property purchase in Tarrytown, New York? Here's what savvy homebuyers need to know when comparing the historic Landmark Condominium to Edge on Hudson developments.
How much can I save choosing Landmark Condo over Edge on Hudson?
The Landmark Condominium offers exceptional value at approximately $500,000—roughly half the price of comparable units at Edge on Hudson. With lower monthly HOA fees ($481/month) and significantly reduced property taxes (approximately $4,381/year), your investment in the Landmark Condo provides both immediate savings and long-term financial benefits that Edge on Hudson simply can't match.
Which property offers better access to Tarrytown amenities?
The Landmark Condominium boasts a remarkable 90/100 walkability score, placing you steps away from Tarrytown Music Hall, diverse restaurants, boutique shops, and the Metro-North station. While Edge on Hudson offers river views, the Landmark Condo puts you directly in the heart of historic Tarrytown, providing immediate access to the authentic village lifestyle that makes this area so desirable.
How do the commuting options compare between these properties?
Both locations offer access to NYC, but the Landmark Condo provides superior convenience with just a 5-minute walk to the Metro-North station for a 40-minute ride to Grand Central. Edge on Hudson residents typically face a longer walk to the station. For NYC professionals seeking an efficient commute alongside Tarrytown's charm, the Landmark Condominium offers the ideal balance.
What are the lifestyle differences between these Tarrytown properties?
The Landmark Condominium offers a "lock-and-leave" lifestyle with low maintenance living in a historic building with unique architectural character. Edge on Hudson provides newer construction with modern amenities but lacks the authentic charm and established community feeling. The Landmark Condo connects you immediately to Tarrytown's vibrant cultural scene centered around the iconic Tarrytown Music Hall.
Which Tarrytown property represents the better long-term investment?
Historic properties in walkable locations like the Landmark Condominium have consistently maintained their value in Westchester County. While Edge on Hudson offers newer construction, you'll pay a significant premium for it. The Landmark Condo's combination of historic character, prime location, and price point represents a rare opportunity to invest in Tarrytown real estate at half the cost of new developments, with proven appreciation potential.
Edge on Hudson vs Landmark Condo: The Best Tarrytown Real Estate Value in 2025
Looking for the perfect Tarrytown property? As local real estate prices continue to climb, savvy buyers are comparing options to find the best value. We answer the most common questions about why the Landmark Condominium offers unbeatable value compared to Edge on Hudson and other new developments.
How much can I save choosing Landmark Condo over Edge on Hudson?
The Landmark Condominium offers exceptional value at approximately half the price of comparable Edge on Hudson properties. With starting prices significantly lower, lower monthly HOA fees ($481 compared to $800+), and more reasonable property taxes, the long-term savings are substantial. This price advantage allows buyers to enjoy Tarrytown's charm without the premium price tag of new construction.
Which location offers better walkability - Edge on Hudson or Landmark Condo?
The Landmark Condominium boasts a superior 90/100 walkability score, with immediate access to Tarrytown's historic Main Street. Unlike Edge on Hudson, which requires walking uphill to reach village amenities, Landmark residents step outside to find the Tarrytown Music Hall, local shops, restaurants, and the Metro-North station all within a 5-minute walk. This central location eliminates the need for daily driving.
How do the commute options compare between these Tarrytown properties?
Both locations offer Metro-North access, but the Landmark Condominium provides a more convenient 5-minute walk to the station versus a longer walk from Edge on Hudson. From either location, you'll enjoy a 40-minute train ride to Grand Central, making Tarrytown ideal for NYC professionals seeking better quality of life without sacrificing convenient commuting.
Which property offers better investment potential in Tarrytown's market?
The Landmark Condominium represents a stronger investment opportunity due to its lower entry price, central location, and historic character. While Edge on Hudson offers new construction, the Landmark's established presence in Tarrytown's historic district, proximity to cultural amenities, and lower carrying costs create a compelling value proposition for long-term appreciation and rental potential.
What lifestyle differences should buyers consider between these properties?
Edge on Hudson offers a newer, more homogeneous community with river views and amenities like pools. The Landmark Condominium provides a more authentic Tarrytown experience with immediate access to the village's historic charm, cultural venues like the Tarrytown Music Hall, and established neighborhood character. The Landmark is ideal for those seeking a lock-and-leave lifestyle with walkable access to everything Tarrytown offers.
Landmark Condominium in Tarrytown, NY | Steps from Music Hall | Edge on Hudson Alternative
Experience the charm of owning a unique Landmark Condo in historic Tarrytown, New York. This property offers a perfect blend of modern living and small-town character, just steps away from the iconic Tarrytown Music Hall, Metro-North station, and vibrant Main Street shops and restaurants. Enjoy all the benefits of a walkable, cultural neighborhood at half the price of Edge on Hudson properties!
Photo Gallery of The Landmark Condominium Unit #402 - On sale: $500,000
Edge on Hudson vs Landmark Condo: The Best Tarrytown Real Estate Value in 2025
Considering a property purchase in Tarrytown? Before making a decision, explore this comprehensive comparison between Edge on Hudson and the historic Landmark Condominium to find the best value for your investment.
Which offers better value: Edge on Hudson or the Landmark Condo?
Dollar for dollar, the Landmark Condominium offers significantly better value than Edge on Hudson. While Edge on Hudson properties start at around $1.2 million for comparable square footage, the Landmark Condo provides similar amenities at approximately half the price. Additionally, the Landmark's central location in historic Tarrytown offers immediate access to established community amenities without waiting for development completion.
How do monthly costs compare between Edge on Hudson and Landmark Condos?
The Landmark Condominium features a competitive $481 monthly HOA fee that covers all common area maintenance, exterior building upkeep, snow removal, and trash service. This is considerably lower than Edge on Hudson's HOA fees, which typically exceed $800 monthly. Additionally, property taxes for the established Landmark building are generally more predictable than those for new construction at Edge on Hudson.
Which location offers better walkability and convenience?
The Landmark Condominium offers superior walkability with a Walk Score of 85/100. Located in the heart of Tarrytown, residents enjoy immediate access to the Metro-North station (5-minute walk), Tarrytown Music Hall, local restaurants, cafes, and shops. While Edge on Hudson offers Hudson River views, residents must walk uphill to reach Main Street amenities or drive to most daily conveniences, making the Landmark Condo more practical for car-free or car-lite lifestyles.
What are the lifestyle differences between Edge on Hudson and the Landmark Condo?
The Landmark Condo offers an authentic small-town experience with immediate integration into Tarrytown's historic community. Residents become part of the established neighborhood fabric with its local businesses, community events, and village charm. Edge on Hudson provides a more exclusive, resort-style environment with newer amenities but a more isolated community experience as the development continues to be built out over the coming years.
Which property will likely appreciate more by 2030?
While new construction at Edge on Hudson commands premium pricing today, historic properties in established locations like the Landmark Condominium have demonstrated remarkable stability and appreciation in Westchester County. The Landmark's location in the heart of Tarrytown, combined with its historic character and walkability, positions it for strong appreciation potential as buyers increasingly value established communities with authentic character over newer developments.
What commuting options are available from each location?
Both properties offer access to NYC commuting options, but in different ways. The Landmark Condominium is a 5-minute walk to the Tarrytown Metro-North station with 40-minute express trains to Grand Central. Edge on Hudson offers a shuttle service to the station but requires timing your departure around the shuttle schedule. For drivers, both locations provide similar access to major highways, though the Landmark's central location gives slightly faster access to the Tappan Zee Bridge.